The Barna Group‘s latest research reveal indicates that most Americans want a customized religious experience. http://www.usatoday.com/NEWS/usaedition/2011-09-13-If-World-War-IIera-warbler-Kate_ST_U.htm The research, as summarized in the USA Today article, suggests that Americans shop for their religious believes like accessories to the self. That is, Leslie’s religion reflects her preferences and is absent of the convictions or statements that make her uncomfortable. For example, the article cites that there is an increased belief among individuals in Jesus as their personal savior as well as the conviction that they are going to heaven however none have attended church in the last 6 months other than for a special event such as wedding or funeral.
While their contribution to the conversation is helpful, it may be true that the Barna research is playing a tired chord within an over-played song. That chord is that people are mindless without the church; clergy have lost their persuasive abilities and that the church is fractured because of both the previous points. What if the chord was transposed just a note or two higher? It might sound like this, people are still striving to be found faithful in an increasingly complex world; Clergy have never been persuasive apart from their care to people by which their study of the gospel is fully informed; and the church has never been of one mind or expression about anything. Such a higher note might allow us to honor gospel fundamentals without grasping at trendy straws in order to solve what is uncomfortable about the church’s life. After all being the church means being fundamentally uncomfortable.
Quite contrary to Barna’s concerns, religious experience is fundamentally customized (that is the essence of believing in a personal God). Customization is not something that people do artificially because clergy and the church have lost control.
In the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) we believe in the aggregate of experience that informs the entire Body of Christ. So, my customized religious experience is put alongside others who have a distinct customized experience. If there is the right spirit between us, I am interested not only in my experience but in the experience of my fellow worshiper and church-goer. The shared life, then is a creative mix of the customized.
Research like Barna’s is the most recent arrival in a long line of laments that mainline Christianity is on the way down and out. This anxious cry is becoming increasingly impotent. This is the cry that would have us all trying harder to keep up with insatiable expectations for the church. Some of our expectations for Christianity in the United Stated of American cannot be satisfied. We expect more and more. Increasing demands include more attendance, more income, more members, more successful programs. Perhaps these insatiable demands are what drive people from organized religion to find some relief. It seems to me that there is a natural ebb and flow in the organized life of the church. If we are truly in an ebb, perhaps it is a good time to dig down and serve those gathered with greater personal attention to their customized experience so that it can inform our shared life in creative ways that contribute to the next flow from an abundant God.
After all the fundamental expectation for Christ‘s church is not just rapid appeal and growth. There is also the relational work that serves as scaffolding to the Body of Christ. In this relational work, we taken on tough questions as we figure out the customized experience of “the other” person….specifically the person who seems miles from our own experience. This work is not for those who believe they are going to heaven because they prefer to….this is the work of those who are wondering, hoping and working ….doubting that their customized faith is all there is. This has always been the work of an inner circle of customized individuals who prepare to interact intensely with God’s wider world.
Related articles
- USA Today: More Americans Tailoring Religion to Fit their Needs (frozenclocks.wordpress.com)
- Barna: What Self-Described Christians Must Overcome (5ptsalt.com)